VertRep

VertRep

Friday, March 16, 2007

Ballistic Missile Defense: South Korea seeking Patriots


South Korea is going to take BMD into its own hands, as reported here:
South Korea's groundbreaking efforts to develop a ballistic missile defense strategy based on its unique security challenges and its limited resources took a novel turn this week: The Seoul government started negotiations with Germany to buy second-hand, U.S.-built Patriot anti-ballistic missile interceptors.

The Korea Times reported Tuesday that senior South Korean and Germany defense officials had that same day initiated three days of discussions focused on Seoul's efforts to buy second-hand, U.S.-built Patriot interceptors from Berlin and boost bilateral cooperation. The newspaper cited the South Korean Defense Acquisition Program Administration, or DAPA, as its source.

"High on the agenda is Seoul's purchase of second-hand Patriot anti-missile systems from the European country," the newspaper said, quoting DAPA officials.

U.S. defense contractors were no doubt disappointed that South Korea has not proved a lucrative market for new patriot PAC-3s, as neighboring Japan has been. But they were hardly surprised. As we have reported in these columns in December, South Korean leader have made far-reaching strategic decision to pursue relatively extensive BMD capabilities against the potential threat from neighboring North Korea, but they are trying to keep their expenditures reined in.
***
As we have previously noted Seoul, with a population of 14 million, or around a quarter the population of South Korea, is within range of at least 11,000 short-range missiles and artillery tubes of the North Korean Army deployed on the other side of the Demilitarized Zone. Therefore focusing on low-level anti-ballistic missile interceptor batteries like the Patriot, rather than opting for more higher-altitude interception systems such as the GBIs, the SM-3s, THAAD or even Israel's Arrow interceptor, makes sense for South Korean planners.

In fact, South Korea already deploys some SM-2 Block IIIA interceptors on its own U.S.-built Aegis class destroyers.

Thursday, March 15, 2007

Don't fall for the hype: GAO study of LNG terror threat not complete


As set out here, and contrary to the headlines proclaiming LNG as the devil's tool sample Boston Herald headline, "LNG tanker attack seen as catastrophe") - what the GAO really said was, "we need more information."
GAO says LNG tanker terror attack consequences need more study

The GAO has issued a report saying that the "public safety consequences" of a terrorist attack on an LNG tanker "need clarification."

The report was released yesterday by the House Committee on Energy and Commerce, which is planning to hold hearings.

The report has already been seized on by opponents of LNG terminals and generated one Massachusetts headline proclaiming: "Reports say terror attack could burn people one mile away."

What does the report, in fact, say?
As the article says, download it here (get the full pdf) and read it for yourself.

From page 12 of the report:
Specifically, all experts did not agree with the heat impact distance of 1,600 meters. Seven of 15 experts thought Sandia’s distance was “about right,” and the remaining eight experts were evenly split as to whether the distance was “too conservative” or “not conservative enough” (the other 4 experts did not answer this question). Experts also did not agree with the Sandia National Laboratories’ conclusion that only three of the five LNG tanks on a tanker would be involved in a cascading failure. Finally, experts suggested priorities to guide future research aimed at clarifying uncertainties about heat impact distances and cascading failure, including large-scale fire experiments, large-scale LNG spill experiments on water, the potential for cascading failure of multiple LNG tanks, and improved modeling techniques. DOE’s recently funded study involving large-scale LNG fire experiments addresses some, but not all, of the research priorities identified by the expert panel.

Wednesday, March 14, 2007

Japan and Australia sign defense agreement

Reported here:
Japan and Australia signed a defense pact Tuesday, committing the two nations to cooperation on military, antiterrorism, and security matters.

Bloomberg reports that the defense pact, signed by Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe and Australian Prime Minister John Howard, will partner the two countries "on disaster relief, border security and fighting terrorism," and will include cooperation and personnel exchange between the Japanese and Australian militaries.
***

Japan and Australia signed a defense pact Tuesday, committing the two nations to cooperation on military, antiterrorism, and security matters.

Bloomberg reports that the defense pact, signed by Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe and Australian Prime Minister John Howard, will partner the two countries "on disaster relief, border security and fighting terrorism," and will include cooperation and personnel exchange between the Japanese and Australian militaries.
***
The pact is Japan's first permanent military arrangement since World War II with a nation other than the US.

The Asia Times reports that the "historic joint security declaration" may be "partly aimed at diluting the widespread public impression in both countries that their leaders focus too much on their alliance with the US."
China, of course, expresses concern:
...Chinese news agency Xinhua reports that Chinese Foreign Ministry spokesman Qin Gang said that he hopes that the Australia-Japan pact will take Chinese concerns into account.

"China pursues the road of peaceful development. The modernization of our armed forces is defensive in nature," he said. "We hope the relevant countries can objectively understand China's foreign and defense policies," he added.

When commenting on statements by the Australian and Japanese leaders that their security pact is not aimed at China, Qin said "we hope what they said is true."

"China will not invade or threaten other countries, so we have nothing to fear. We remain unperturbed," Qin said.

Navy Helo Squadrons Honor Fallen Shipmates


LantFlt helo squadrons honor a fallen comrade as set out in Helo Squadrons Come Together to Honor Fallen Shipmate:
Sailors assigned to Helicopter Sea Combat Squadron (HSC) 28, HSC-2, HSC-22 and HSC-26 participated in a "missing man" formation during the funeral of Lt. Adam Dyer, of HSC-23, at Arlington National Cemetery on March 9.

Dyer and three other crew members assigned to HSC-23, based at Naval Air Station North Island, Calif., died when their Navy MH-60S Knighthawk helicopter crashed into the Pacific Ocean while conducting a routine training mission off USS Bonhomme Richard (LHD 6) near San Clemente Island on Jan. 26.

"Lt. Adam Dyer wanted to be buried at the Arlington National Cemetery and the Helicopter Sea Combat Wing Atlantic volunteered the aircraft, therefore, we took a helo from four squadrons that fly '60S' within the wing and did the formation," said Lt. Cmdr. Kirk Hansen, HSC-28 "Dragon Whales" operations officer.

A missing man formation consists of four aircraft in a formation shape of a "V," with the right arm, from the pilotsí perspective, longer than the left. When the "V" passes over the ceremonial site, the aircraft in the "ring-finger" position pulls up and leaves the formation, to signify a lost comrade in arms.
***
"This is an opportunity to honor a shipmate and carry out their wishes and anybody that flyís a ë60í is a friend of ours," said Lt. Ethan Lust, HSC-28 Naval air training and operating procedures standardization officer.

Besides Dyer and Will, the other two crewmembers who died in the crash were Lt. j.g. Laura J. Mankey and Aviation Warfare Systems Operator 1st Class Cory J. Helman.
As the father of an H-60S pilot, I offer up my own small salute to all the lost crew and their families.

Article by Mass Communication Specialist 3rd Class Kenneth Ray Hendrix, Fleet Public Affairs Center Atlantic.

Helicoper recovery from sea set out here. Initial report of crash here.

Yemen News


There's a lot of unpleasant things happening in Yemen and, lucky for us, Jane keeps an eye on them (and on some Somalia stuff, too) at Armies of Liberation.

Recommended reading.

Quick, tell the oil companies!


Hey, Chevron! Hey, Exxon and Shell! Here's challenge for you- recover hydrocarbons from Saturn moon:
Nasa's Cassini probe has found evidence for seas, probably filled with liquid hydrocarbons, at the high northern latitudes of Saturn's moon Titan.

The dark features, detected by Cassini's radar, are much bigger than any lakes already detected on Titan.

The largest is some 100,000 sq km (39,000 sq miles) - greater in extent than North America's Lake Superior.

It covers a greater fraction of Titan than the proportion of Earth covered by the Black Sea.

The Black Sea is the Earth's largest inland sea and covers about 0.085% of our planet's surface.
***
While there is no definitive proof that these seas contain liquid, their shape, their dark appearance in radar that indicates smoothness, along with other properties, point to the presence of liquids.

The liquids are probably a combination of methane and ethane, given the conditions on Titan and the abundance of methane and ethane gases and clouds in Titan's atmosphere.
More here from NASA. Including an animation found here.

Fake drugs from China

Security issue raised here:
The shocking scale of China's counterfeit medicine business was exposed in a recent sampling of drugs in Southeast Asia by Oxford University's Centre for Tropical Medicine in Vientiane, Laos. The centre reportedly found bogus antibiotics, tuberculosis drugs, AIDS anti-retrovirals and meningitis vaccines. A total of 53 percent of the anti-malarial drugs tested were fakes, and a charity in Myanmar that bought 100,000 tablets found they were all counterfeit.

Wrapped in packaging complete with anti-forgery holograms - and even cause convincing side effects in patients - the bogus medicine is difficult to spot, and as a doctor at the Laos centre said, the drugs were not being produced in someone's kitchen but "on an industrial scale".
***
It is the bargain-hunting consumer who revs the engine driving the pirate business, but unlike the masses of pirated blockbuster movies on the streets of Asia and copied fashion items, there are some products that the consumer would be happy to pay top dollar for. Life-saving medicines, for instance. Or aircraft parts.

Drug companies need to secure their supplies and ensure their 3PLs - in-house or out - have the security in place to prevent bogus medicine flooding legitimate markets. And wholesale buyers of medicine such as charities and national health departments should understand that when it comes to sourcing critical drugs, bargain hunting is just asking to be ripped off.

Singapore investment in Panama Canal




International business makes for interesting investments as is the case here:
PSA International yesterday made a formal announcement of its plans to build and operate a container terminal at the Pacific entrance of the Panama Canal. The terminal at Rodman marks PSA's first ever port investment in the Americas and is the second major investment by Singapore in Panama, following a Free Trade Agreement entered between the two countries a year ago.
***
In its first phase, the PSA Panama International Terminal project will involve the construction of a 330-metre container and roll-on-roll-off berth which will be able to handle about 450,000 twenty-foot equivalent units (TEUs) of containers per year. The berth's 14-metre water depth will enable the terminal to handle post-panamax ships.

The project to develop Rodman into a major port facility on the Pacific coast comes in tandem with the widening and expansion of the Panama Canal, which is currently underway. The people of Panama voted in a public referendum on Oct 22, agreeing to a US$5.25 billion plan to enlarge the canal to accommodate new, super-large containerships. There has been some pressure from environmentalists against the widening, and shipping trade groups are up in arms against increased canal toll rates being levied to finance the development programme.

At an announcement ceremony yesterday in Panama City, PSA International Group CEO Eddie Teh said that for Singapore and Panama, whose ports are important transhipment hubs, the development of their maritime infrastructure is 'paramount to both our economies and to world trade'.

'Both Panama and Singapore are located at the major crossroads of shipping. The Panama Canal and the Malacca Straits represent the two most important and strategic waterways in the world. Both nations have major roles to play and contribute towards the facilitation of world trade,' he added.

PSA said its collaboration with Panama in this area of maritime infrastructure development would 'serve to add impetus to the flow of world trade between Asia, the Americas, Europe and beyond'.
***
Panama currently has four main container terminals, including one on the Pacific coast at the Port of Balboa - Port Terminal SA, which is operated by Hong Kong's Hutchison Port Holdings. The remaining three are located on the Atlantic coast, Manzanillo International Terminal, operated by Stevedoring Services of America; Colon Container Terminal, operated by Taiwan's Evergreen Marine; and Colon Port Terminal, also operated by Hutchison Port Holdings. The 77 km canal handles 13,000 ships a year with 5 per cent of the global maritime market.

Tuesday, March 13, 2007

2007 MilBlog Conference: Pre-Registration is Now Open

Now is the time: 2007 MilBlog Conference: Pre-Registration is Now Open.

Don't be late or you might not get a seat.

Besides, I need people to buy me a beer. Or two.

The Vital Sea Lanes


From a speech by the Deputy Prime Minister of Indonesia found here:
Located between Malaysia, Indonesia and Singapore, the Malacca strait is one of the most important shipping lanes in the world, and one of the most endangered. About 60 thousand ships, carrying half the world's oil and more than a third of its economy, pass it every year. This makes it one of the most important shipping lanes in the whole world, equivalent in its importance to the Suez or Panama Canal.
***
The strait's economic importance drew the attention of a threat, which seemed long forgotten in marine history: piracy. A threat which grew so eminent, that the Lloyd Market's Association (an insurance company) declared the Malacca Straits an area that is in jeopardy of "war, strikes, terrorism and related perils" in 2005. The LMA revoked this decision later in August 2006. Nevertheless, in 2004, from all the piracy crimes worldwide, 40 percent were committed in this area.

After the 9/11 attacks on World Trade Centre, another frightening scenario rose in the heads of analysts. A terror attack in this area could critically wound one of world trade's most important veins, leading to an economic collapse in this region.

If terrorists would sink a ship at the most shallow part of the strait, no ship could pass through and the whole traffic would be blocked. Fears rose, when video footage of Malaysian police patrols along the Malacca Straits, appeared on the al-Qaeda network, suggesting there was already a plan in progress.

"After 9/11 we were worried about a connection between pirates and al-Qaeda. But we are tracking this very closely and I can assure you that there is no evidence for such a case so far," the deputy prime minister ensured the audience.
Sea lanes? Background here.

Coming soon? A toll Strait?


User fee for the Strait of Malacca suggested: here:
Countries and companies that use the Straits of Malacca and Singapore must bear the estimated US$300 million (euro250 million) cost required to enhance safety on the increasingly busy waterways, a Japanese group said.

Some 94,000 vessels, amounting to 4 billion dead weight tonnage (DWT), passed through the Straits of Malacca and Singapore last year and the number is expected to surge to 141,000, totaling about 6.4 billion DWT, by 2020, said Yohei Sasakawa, chairman of the Nippon Foundation, a private Japaneseorganization.

"The introduction of new (navigational safety) measures is estimated to cost US$300 million over the next decade," Sasakawa told a conference in Kuala Lumpur on safety and environmental protection in both straits.

"The burden should be shared equitably between the relevant parties."
Naturally, the states along the strait are concerned about sovereignty:
Deputy Prime Minister Najib Razak said major user states and shipowners must provide more financial and technical assistance, but that their input should not encroach on the sovereignty of the littoral states.

"Navigation safety in the straits should not be taken for granted by the international community," Najib said in his speech, which was read to the conference by Transport Minister Chan Kong Choy. "It should be the collective responsibility of the users as well as the littoral states." Najib was overseas.

Chan later told reporters the littoral states welcomed contributions in the form of technical aid, training programs and funds, but reiterated that a foreign military presence was not needed to secure the Malacca Strait.
Floating toll booths, anyone?

E Asian missile defenses and more


Interview with Admiral Dennis Blair, former CINCPAC, from ISN Security Watch. Well worth the read, as he assesses the rise of China's military, the threat posed by the DPRK and more. Excerpt:
USAPC: What do you see happening region-wide in ballistic missile defense?

Blair: Things are very dynamic. In terms of military developments in Asia, it has been in the area of missiles and missile defenses that we have seen the most activity in recent years. In Northeast Asia, for example, China is developing many more missile systems of all types of mobility and ranges. North Korea has been putting considerable effort into its missile development program. You will recall the "fireworks display" last July 4 when Pyongyang tested a long-range ballistic missile and several shorter range missiles.

Meanwhile, the United States has been putting tremendous effort and resources into developing a missile system for Asia. Recently, we successfully tested a very capable ground-based missile defense system called THAAD, or Theater High Altitude Air Defense, by intercepting a challenging test target over the Pacific. Japan, too, has been cooperating more with the United States on missile defense, especially on the development of the Standard sea-based missile, and in deploying tracking radars aimed at North Korea.

USAPC: North Korea appears determined to show off its missile prowess, but does this pose an actual military threat to South Korea or Japan?

Blair: North Korea certainly could do damage to South Korea, Japan, and China with its short- and medium-range missiles. But if you look at the use of bombing in warfare through the years -- whether it be the German V-1s and V-2s in World War II or the Iraqi Scuds that were fired at Saudi Arabia and Israel during the Persian Gulf War – history has shown that missile attacks create a certain psychological terror in the early stages, but then people in the targeted countries learn to endure them. So North Korea's missile threat certainly has a psychological effect on Japan, but less so on South Korea because the South Koreans have lived with the artillery threat from North Korea for generations what with Seoul being within 20 miles of the DMZ (de-militarized zone).

In addition, from a military point of view, missiles do not cause much serious military damage because defenses can be erected against them in the form of movement and concealment, thicker concrete, and sandbags. For fixed sites, I think North Korea's missile program has been primarily for use as weapons of terror or bargaining chips. The missiles themselves would not have a serious military effect.

There is a tremendous difference, however, if there is a nuclear warhead on one of the missiles. The North Koreans must consider the retaliatory capability of the United States in any calculation involving deployment of a nuclear weapon. In fact, we know from North Korean defectors that North Korean officials are aware that if they would be rash or stupid enough to fire a nuclear weapon at Japan, South Korea, U.S. forces, or the United States, they would be subject to such terrible retaliation that Kim Jong-Il's regime and a large part of North Korea would be wiped off the map.

So I don't think North Korea's nuclear test in October 2006 fundamentally has changed the military facts on the ground. Nonetheless, the nuclear test represents the kind of North Korean brinkmanship that causes problems if you are trying to achieve a sensible, peaceful solution that would make the lives of people better in that part of the world. That is what is so troubling about the Kim regime. It has no objectives other than its own survival. It starves and kills many of its own people. It terrorizes and tries to get advantages from its neighbors.

The Sounds of Silence

Or, What if Fox News threw a Democratic Debate.....

Freedom of speech? Their speech...
Freedom of the press? Their press...
Freedom to disagree with them? PC less...

Monday, March 12, 2007

Another voice concerned about Iranian "stealth" missile systems - launches from cargo ships off U.S. and Israel


Found at China Confidential: Iran Developing Stealth Strike Capabilities:
After the attacks of 9/11, the thought of an implacable Islamist enemy in possession of atomic warheads and intercontinental ballistic missiles is truly terrifying.

The consensus is that Iran already has missiles capable of striking US military bases in the Persian Gulf and Iraq, as well as targets in Israel, Jordan, Saudi Arabia and Turkey. The monstrous mullahocracy may also be able to reach parts of Germany and Italy, but is thought to be several years away from being able to accurately strike at targets throughout Europe; and an Iranian ICBM capable of hitting the continental US is not even on the proverbial radar screen.

But there is increasing concern that Iran could be developing an immediate missile threat--to the US--as China Confidential has reported in the past. Some Israeli and US analysts contend that the oil-rich, neo-Nazi-supporting Islamist nation--the world leader in state sponsored terrorism and Holocaust denial--is actively developing conventional, sea-based methods for launching stealth attacks on coastal cities with cruise missiles and short- and medium-range missiles.
***
Roughly 70 percent of Israel's population lives in the narrow Mediterranean coastal strip in the two major population centers of Tel Aviv and Haifa. The consequences of any missile attack with weapons of mass destruction on the region would be devastating, both in numbers of people lost and in economic upheaval. Israel is essentially a one-bomb country in terms of its vulnerability to atomic attack.

Similarly, some 75 percent of the US population lives within 200 miles of the US coastline. Nuclear-tipped missile strikes could cripple the country. The destruction caused by a nuclear warhead detonating in the air over the nation's capital would make the 9/11 attacks look mild by comparison.
***
The most plausible sea-based attack scenarios are described below.

(1) SCUD-IN-A-BUCKET: Foreign flagged commercial ships could carry Russian designed Scuds or Chinese Silkworm cruise missiles for easy launch from international waters. Some types of dry cargo ships could launch the missiles from their holds. A container ship could conceal a missile and launch mechanism in an innocent looking shipping container on top of its deck before authorities even knew that an attack was in progress. Iran and North Korea have successfully test-fired Scuds from cargo ships. And the US itself experimented with the technique back in the early 1960s.

(2) CANISTER-LAUNCH: The Soviet Union developed this technique during the Cold War. It involves placing a ballistic missile in a sealed tube and dropping it in the sea from the deck of a commercial vessel. The bottom of the tube, sealed off from the missile, is weighted with ballast to achieve a specific level of buoyancy to ensure that the nose of the missile points up just enough to barely break the sea’s surface. After an interval to allow the mother ship to move on--and maybe drop off other encapsulated missiles--the rockets could be remotely launched or fired by timers and guided to their targets by the ship's commercial GPS system.
You know, if I was in Europe or Australia, I wouldn't be too comfortable either.

Earlier posts on this topic
Maritime Security: A "Real Missile Threat?"
, This can't be good news: "DoD Finds Cruise Missile Defense 'Gaps'", and North Korean Missile/Cargo Ships.

More scenarios at MissileThreat.com.

UPDATE: And remember, they don't have to actually hit a land mass to do damage. As quoted here:
An EMP attack damages all unprotected electronic equipment within the blast's "line of sight" (the EMP's "footprint" on the earth's surface). The size of the footprint is determined by the altitude of the explosion. The higher the altitude, the greater the land area affected. A Scud-type ballistic missile launched from a vessel in U.S. coastal waters and detonated at an altitude of 95 miles could degrade electronic systems across one-quarter of the United States. A more powerful missile launched from North Korea could probably deliver a warhead 300 miles above America--enough to degrade the electronic systems across the entire continental United States.
China Confidential's earlier post on the sea-going SCUD cooperation between North Korea and Iran here.

Railroad tank car security: Propane train goes boom!


Following up expressions of concern over gas carying railroad tank cars comes news of railroad propane tank cars burning after a derailment in upstate New York:
A freight train carrying propane gas derailed and caught fire outside Oneida in New York state on Monday, forcing the evacuation of people within a one-mile (1.6 km) radius, fire officials said.

Twelve cars were burning but no one was injured.

The 80-car train derailed on the outskirts of the city, where several hundred people and including some schools were evacuated, said Lt. Kevin Salerno of the Oneida Fire Department.
***
The twelve cars, which appeared to be propane tankers, were still burning about two hours after the accident, but the flames had been reduced, according to Salerno.

"They were a couple hundred feet in the air. You could see them over the trees," he said. "We're kind of in a valley here so from the hills you could probably see them for 10 or 15 miles (16 to 25 km)."
More news here, from whence the picture was liberated.

UPDATE: Oddly enough, the Council on Foreign Relations just addressed some rail security issues here in a piece titled "Rail Security and the Terrorist Threat." Nice opening:
High profile terrorist attacks on rail systems in Madrid, London, and Mumbai provide troubling illustration to persistent warnings that the U.S. public transportation system is a vulnerable target for terrorists. But passenger rail is not the only, and perhaps not even the gravest concern. Much of the 160,000 miles of railroad track in the United States transports freight, including highly toxic chemicals. These shipments often have minimal security, even though they pass through populated areas, endangering thousands of lives.
Just for fun, take a look at the map, which shows "binational" railroads (those "Serving binational trade between the U.S. and Mexico."). Think about how many more lines there are...
(you can look at a map of U.S. railroads by going here and clicking on the map below the headline "2004 Edition! Railroads of the Continental United States")

Maritime Monday 50 at Fred Fry International

Yes, it's that time again. Try reading Fred Fry International: Maritime Monday 50 to satisfy that itch you've got for all things maritime related.

Sunday, March 11, 2007

Sunday Ship History: The Coast Guard Auxiliary

30,000 strong, rankless (those rank-like devices indicate the job they hold, not a rank) and volunteers--- the U.S. Coast Guard Auxiliary.

So who are these men and women who contribute a couple of million hours of time to helping boaters and providing services under the Coast Guard umbrella?

In the beginning, there was the United States Coast Guard. And that was it. Then, as prosperity and mass production allowed more Americans to enjoy personal pleasure boating, the Coast Guard was taxed to the limit in keeping up with the demand. As is the case in such times of need, there came an idea, as set out by John A, Tiley of East Carolina University:
The 1915 act creating the Coast Guard described it as "an armed service," but it differed from the Army and the Navy in at least one fundamental respect: The Coast Guard had no peacetime reserve. The idea of creating one had surfaced occasionally (the oldest reference to such a concept dates from 1851), but the federal government had never acted on it.

In the summer of 1934 a yachtsman named Malcolm Stuart Boylan planted the seed that eventually sprouted as the U.S. Coast Guard Auxiliary. Boylan had just been elected commodore of the newly-created Pacific Writers' Yacht Club, which was about to undertake a cruise from its home in Los Angeles to Catalina Island. Boylan asked a Coast Guard acquaintance, LTCDR C.W. Thomas of the cutter Hermes, to inspect the club's boats before their departure.

Another of the Hermes's officers, LT F.C. Pollard, made the trip to Catalina on board Boylan's yacht, and the two men had a long discussion about the relationship between the Coast Guard and the boating community. On August 23, 1934, Boylan sent Pollard a letter outlining a basic concept for a Coast Guard reserve: ...A Coast Guard Reserve would be an excellent thing to perpetuate its traditions, preserve its entity and, more particularly, to place at the disposal of CG officers, auxiliary flotillas of small craft for the frequent emergencies incident to your...duties. A copy of Boylan's letter made its way to Washington, and to the desk of CDR Russell Waesche, an aide to the Commandant of the Coast Guard. Waesche saw merit in the idea, but it languished for some five years.

In 1936 Waesche was promoted to rear-admiral and appointed Commandant. He was a forceful, energetic man, and the creation of a Coast Guard reserve became one of his favorite projects. With the backing of the Secretary of Commerce, the Secretary of the Navy, and several influential Congressmen, RADM Waesche finally was able to gain Congressional approval for the concept.

The Coast Guard Reserve Act of 1939, passed on June 23 of that year, created an institution that was unique in the federal government. The new Reserve was to have four broadly-defined purposes:

In the interest of (a) safety to life at sea and upon the navigable waters, (b) the promotion of efficiency in the operation of motorboats and yachts, and (c) a wider knowledge of, and better compliance with, the laws, rules, and regulations governing the operation and navigation of motorboats and yachts, and (d) facilitating certain operations of the Coast Guard, there is hereby established a United States Coast Guard Reserve...which shall be composed of citizens of the United States and its Territories and possessions...who are owners (sole or in part) or motorboats or yachts....
There was a rub, as is often the case, too. Unlike the Army or Naval Reserve, the Coast Guard Reserve consisted of civilians. Perhaps experienced boat owners and even veterans of wars, but civilians nonetheless. As such, they could not be ordered to active duty. As Tilley's tale continues:
By June of 1940 CDR Merlin O'Neill, the first Chief Director, and his District Directors had enrolled twenty-six hundred men and twenty-three hundred boats in the Coast Guard Reserve. With the support of ADM Waesche, Coast Guard bases began offering training courses for reservists. Those who passed the courses were appointed to three "reserve grades": Senior Navigator, Navigator, and Engineer.
***
In its original form the Coast Guard Reserve lasted less than two years. By early 1941 the Coast Guard was preparing for war. Events in Europe had demonstrated what demands for manpower and boats the service could expect to confront when, as now seemed inevitable, the United States entered the Second World War.

On February 19, 1941 Congress passed a law restructuring the Coast Guard Reserve. Henceforth the Coast Guard was to operate two reserve forces. The existing civilian reserve organization was renamed the U.S. Coast Guard Auxiliary. A new U.S. Coast Guard Reserve was to function on a military basis as a source of wartime manpower, like the reserves of the other armed services.

Members of the new Coast Guard Reserve were to be divided into two categories. "Regular Reservists" were paid for their services, had to meet normal military physical standards, and when on active duty could be assigned to stations anywhere the Coast Guard deemed appropriate. Men who, for any reason, were unable to meet those requirements were invited to become "temporary members of the reserve." A "Coast Guard TR" was a volunteer who served only in some designated geographic area (usually near his home or workplace) and less than full-time. Age limits for TRs were seventeen and sixty-four, and physical requirements were not stringent. Members of the Auxiliary were invited to enroll in the Reserve as TRs - and bring their boats with them.

The officers running the Coast Guard appreciated the staggering demands that war would put on it, and the value of the new reserve system in helping them meet those demands. By the summer of 1941 the District Commanders were sending Coast Guard headquarters lists of boats owned by Auxiliarists that would make good patrol craft - and requisitioning Lewis machine guns, Thompson submachine guns, rifles, and pistols for them.

On November 1, 1941, President Roosevelt signed an order transferring the Coast Guard from the Treasury Department to the Navy Department. A few weeks later the Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor, and the Coast Guard's reserve system was put to the ultimate test. On the night of December 7, amid rumors of Japanese invasion, twenty Coast Guard Auxiliarists from the 13th District took their boats out of Seattle on the service's first wartime patrol cruise. In May, 1942 the Secretary of the Navy authorized uniforms for the Coast Guard Auxiliary.

Between 1941 and 1945 the Auxiliary was the Coast Guard's general-purpose assistant. The Auxiliary was supposed to be, in the words of a headquarters directive of May, 1943, "a civilian organization which is engaged in the training of its members to qualify them for active duty whenever needed with the CG, as temporary members of the CG Reserve." In some districts the Auxiliary did indeed function as a recruiting and training agency for the reserve; the wartime training courses became the nucleus of the Auxiliary's public education program. In other districts the jobs performed by Auxiliarists and Reservists were virtually indistinguishable. No one seemed to mind. Photo:
Coast Guard Auxiliarists advising boaters, Savannah, Georgia, ca. 1942. National Archives
***
Perhaps the Auxiliary's most important contribution to the war effort came in the form of the Volunteer Port Security Force. An executive order of February, 1942 directed the Secretary of the Navy to take the necessary steps to prevent "sabotage and subversive activities" on the nation's waterfronts. The task of protecting the hundreds of warehouses, piers, and other facilities that kept the American shipping industry in business fell to the Coast Guard, which in turn delegated it to the Reserve and the Auxiliary.

in such subjects as anti-espionage methods, fire prevention, customs inspections, and small arms handling. Eventually some twenty thousand Reservists and participated in port security patrols. About two thousand women enrolled as "TR In each port city a Coast Guard officer with the title Captain of the Port was placed in charge of a Port Security Force, consisting of TRs, Auxiliarists, and other civilians recruited for the purpose. The precise organizational structure varied from city to city. The Coast Guard set up a Reserve Training School in Philadelphia to train TRsAuxiliaristsSPARs," attending to the mountainous paper work that dispatched ships, cargoes, and troops overseas.

As the war went on and the Coast Guard's resources were stretched thinner, Auxiliarists and TRs were called upon to fill gaps wherever active duty Coast Guardsmen left them. Auxiliarists' boats patrolled the waterfronts and inlets looking for saboteurs, enemy agents, and fires. At least one unit of temporary Reservists, recruited from the Auxiliary, patrolled east coast beaches on horseback. Other Auxiliarists manned lookout and lifesaving stations near their homes, freeing regular Coast Guardsmen for sea duty. When a flood struck St. Louis in the spring of 1943, Coast Guard Auxiliarists and Reservists evacuated seven thousand people and thousands of livestock. Photo:
Coast Guard reserve members of the beach patrol: mounted and canine units, ca. 1942-45. CGAUX

The Auxiliary and the Reserve attracted their share of celebrity members. Actor Humphrey Bogart took his yacht on several patrols out of Los Angeles, and Arthur Fiedler, conductor of the Boston Pops Orchestra, put in his twelve hours per week on patrol duty in Boston Harbor.

were awarded the Victory Medal. By 1945 the Coast Guard Auxiliary boasted a membership of 67,533, and 53,214 men and women (most of them Auxiliarists) were serving as temporary members of the Reserve. At the end of the war the Coast Guard TRs were "honorably disenrolled." Many remained Auxiliarists for years afterward. Wartime service had earned them no veterans' benefits and precious little other public recognition. In 1946 the TRsAuxiliarists who had not joined the Reserve had to be satisfied with the thanks of ADM Waesche:

The Auxiliary during the war years was indispensable. Many thousands of you served faithfully and loyally as Auxiliarists and as temporary members of the CG Reserve, performing hundreds of tasks and relieving thousands of Coast Guardsmen for duty outside the continental limits. The Coast Guard is deeply appreciative of this service.
After the war, things changed, both for the Coast Guard and the Auxiliary, as set out here:
In any given year, Auxiliary members work an untold number of hours, as they largely administer their own organization. In 1998, their assistance to the public resulted in 445 lives being saved, 12,760 persons being assisted, and a total value of $36.4 million dollars in volunteer services being provided on specific missions.

Following the war, by 1950 the four traditional Auxiliary cornerstone missions of public education, operations, vessel examination, and fellowship had been established. The public education program yearly trains tens of thousands of boaters in seamanship, piloting, rules of the road and weather. Specially qualified coxswain and crew members conduct search and rescue missions in their own boats and support Coast Guard missions. Auxiliary pilots and air observers search for boaters in distress, floating hazards, pollution spills, and ice-locked vessels. Communications watchstanders handle distress calls at Coast Guard and Auxiliary radio stations. Vessel examiners conduct Courtesy Marine Examinations under which recreational vessels are examined for properly installed federally required equipment and systems.

Photo:
Auxiliarists rescue boater off an outboard that had foundered during storm 1967, Long Island Sound, New York.

During the past decades, the Auxiliary has continued to grow in membership which today totals some 34,000 members in the United States and its territories. Training is held at every level from the flotilla to national training schools. Leadership and management training, award programs, and data management systems ensure a high level of professionalism.

Under legislation passed in 1996, the Auxiliary's role was expanded to allow members to assist in any Coast Guard mission, except law enforcement and military operations, as authorized by the Commandant. Thus, Auxiliarists can be found examining commercial fishing vessels, flying in C-130 aircraft, working in Coast Guard offices, and crewing with regulars. In 1999, the three components of the service -- the active duty Coastguardsmen, the Reservists, and Auxiliarists, truly constitute TEAM COAST GUARD.

In any given year, Auxiliary members work an untold number of hours, as they largely administer their own organization. In 1998, their assistance to the public resulted in 445 lives being saved, 12,760 persons being assisted, and a total value of $36.4 million dollars in volunteer services being provided on specific missions.
The current state of the CG Auxiliary:
The Auxiliary's four cornerstones - Vessel Examination, Education, Operations and Fellowship - were established and remain the Auxiliary's pillars in the 1990s.

The Vessel Examination program evolved into the well known Vessel Safety Check (VSC), a free examination available to any recreational boater. VSCs help boaters ensure their craft complies with Federal regulations regarding safety equipment requirements.

As for education, the Auxiliary teaches boating safety to recreational boaters of all ages. The Auxiliary offers Boating Skills and Seamanship (geared toward power boaters) and sailing courses (for sailboaters) as well as basic and advanced navigation courses.

The Auxiliary operates safety and regatta patrols and is an integral part of the Coast Guard Search and Rescue team. Auxiliarists also stand communication watches, assist during mobilization exercises, perform harbor and pollution patrols, provide platforms for unarmed boarding parties and recruit new people for the Service.

Today, as in 1939, auxiliarists are civilian volunteers who are authorized to wear a uniform similar to the Coast Guard Officer's uniform. Distinctive emblems, buttons, insignias, and ribbons are employed to identify the wearer as a member of the Auxiliary. One such insignia is the letter "A" on the shoulder boards of an auxiliarist. Despite their silver shoulder boards (versus gold for Coast Guard officers), auxiliarists hold no rank. The shoulder boards symbolize the office and level to which an individual auxiliarist has been either appointed or elected.

The Auxiliary has members in all 50 states, Puerto Rico, the Virgin Islands, American Samoa, and Guam. Membership is open to men and women, 17 years or older, U.S. citizens of all states and territories, civilians or active duty or former members of any of the uniformed services and their Reserve components, including the Coast Guard. Facility (radio station, boat or aircraft) ownership is desirable but not mandatory.

Although under the authority of the Commandant of the U.S. Coast Guard, the Auxiliary is internally autonomous, operating on four organizational levels: Flotilla, Division, District Regions and National.

* Flotilla - The flotilla is the basic organizational unit of the Auxiliary and is comprised of at least 15 qualified members who carry out Auxiliary program activities. Every auxiliarist is a member of a local flotilla. Each flotilla is headed by a Flotilla Commander (FC).
* Division - For maximum administrative effectiveness in carrying out Auxiliary programs, flotillas in the same general geographic area are grouped into divisions. The division provides administrative, training and supervisory support to flotillas and promotes district policy. Each division is headed by a Division Captain (DCP), and Division Vice Captain (VCP) and usually consists of five or more flotillas.
* District/Region - Flotillas and divisions are organized in districts comparable to the Coast Guard Districts and must be assigned the same district number. Some districts are further divided into regions. The district/region provides administrative and supervisory support to divisions, promotes policies of both the district commander and national Auxiliary comittee. All districts and regions are governed by a District Commodore (DCO), District Vice Commodore (VCO), and District Rear Commodores (RCOs), under the guidance of the Coast Guard District Commander. At this level, Coast Guard officers are assigned to oversee and promote the Auxiliary programs as district Directors of Auxiliary.
* National - The Auxiliary has national officers who are responsible, along with the Commandant, for the administration and policy-making for the entire Auxiliary. These officers comprise the National Executive Committee (NEXCOM) that is composed of the Chief Director of Auxiliary (an Active Duty officer), National Commodore and the National Vice Commodores.

NEXCOM and the National Staff make up the Auxiliary Headquarters organization. The Chief Director is a senior Coast Guard officer and directs the administration of the Auxiliary on policies established by the Commandant. The overall supervision of the Coast Guard Auxiliary is under the Assistant Commandant for Operations (G-O), who reports directly to the Commandant.
Modern work includes assisting clearing safety space on the river near the Kennedy Space Center prior to launches, providing security for the G-8 Summit, the Atlanta Olympic Games and much more.
Photo:
Security patrol, Washington Monument, Memorial Day, Washington, D.C., 2004.



How valuable is this all volunteer organization?
The Coast Guard Auxiliary save taxpayers at least $200 million per year by supplementing civilian volunteer assistance according to a study by Vice Commodore E. W. Edgerton of the U.S. Coast Guard Auxiliary.
***
According to the last published figures the Coast Guard Auxiliary consisted: of 33,000 members, conducted over 38,000 boating safety classes, 161,000 boating safety checks, 30,000 surface patrols and saved 10% of the lives saved by the Coast Guard and prevented the loss of millions of dollars in property. The Auxiliary is credited with helping to reduce the number of fatalities from 10.1 per 100,000 to 5.9 per 100,000 at a cost to each taxpayer of less than one penny a year.
They even buy their own uniforms and provide their own boats.

Offer up a big salute to those who have chosen to serve in this great organization!

Interested in signing up? Go here.


(All photos from here.)

Saturday, March 10, 2007

A new port for North Carolina?


Maybe. See here. Needed? Or is it just pork?

Prior effort at justification here:
At its meeting in Wilmington Dec. 29, the Board of Directors of the N.C. State Ports Authority authorized the CEO to negotiate the purchase of 600 acres of riverfront property in Brunswick County. If the purchase is completed, the Authority plans to build a new port terminal, the North Carolina International Port, to handle 2 million containers (20-foot equivalent units, or TEUs) a year.

“This is a once in a lifetime opportunity,” said Board Chairman Carl J. Stewart Jr. “No other property available in the South Atlantic compares to this property, with good access and compatible zoning already in place.”

Development of this facility would coincide with the projected doubling of the North American container market between now and 2015.

“It’s a unique opportunity to catapult North Carolina into the ranks of major U.S. ports,” said Tom Eagar, Ports Authority CEO. “We are responding to the needs of world trade on a large scale, to the benefit of the entire state.”

The new terminal would multiply the number of jobs already generated by the Ports, both local and statewide – currently estimated at more than 48,000 jobs statewide, as well as creating new local and state tax revenues – now almost $30 million annually.

The project will also provide a gigantic boost to economic development. Major manufacturing and assembly plant site-selection criteria require proximity to deepwater port facilities with global service coverage – such as the DaimlerChrysler plant announced recently in North Charleston, S.C.


This location also affords the opportunity to develop an industrial park for distribution centers or related operations – adding additional jobs to the local economy.

Building a new terminal on the Brunswick County property also provides a better alternative, environmentally and economically, than dredging the Cape Fear River to 48 feet to the Port of Wilmington and enlarging the Port’s footprint. Forecast growth in container traffic worldwide would require a deeper channel for Wilmington to remain competitive. The new property is nine miles from the ocean, while Wilmington is 26.

The location, next to the Military Ocean Terminal at Sunny Point, also supports Department of Defense strategic initiatives.

U.S. Coast Guard Strategy: Read All About It!


Downloadable pdf available here. Click on "Coast Guard Strategy."

From the Letter of Promulgation:
This Strategy identifies strategic priorities for implementation across all Coast Guard missions in support of America’s maritime safety, security, and stewardship interests. It focuses on enhancements to legal regimes, awareness, and operational capabilities that best position the Coast Guard to defeat the asymmetrical, transnational threats America will encounter in the future. We will work with the Congress, our interagency partners, and our state, local, private, and international partners to bring this Strategy to life. As we stand watch, we will build the 21st century Coast Guard America expects and deserves.

The CGS is our compass. We have plotted the course for the future. America’s Coast Guard will be the most capable, adaptive, and responsive multi-mission, maritime and military service in our Nation’s history. We will remain Semper Paratus to answer the call whenever and wherever America needs us.

Offshore California LNG project: Antis play pollution card


After being trumped on safety and security issues, the forces opposed to an offshore LNG terminal off Ventura County now begin an new series of whines "it's ilegal" and "it will won't help with pollution." All set out here:
Promised steps to reduce emissions from tankers and tugboats will more than offset air pollution generated by a proposed liquefied natural gas terminal off the Ventura County coastline, a new environmental impact report on the project concludes. But because those emission reductions won't be restricted to the area near the terminal, local residents won't directly benefit from most of them, the report indicates.
***
Supporters of BHP Billiton's project argue that safety precautions will reduce any risks associated with the transport of flammable cargo to acceptable levels and contend that the state needs to tap new sources of energy.

Project opponents say the risk of a tanker accident, terrorist attack or pipeline rupture is too great. Other critics say the terminal and associated construction and ship traffic would pollute Ventura County's air and have raised questions about the integrity of the regulatory process intended to safeguard the health of local residents.

"For us, this project is illegal to begin with," said Susan Jordan of the California Coastal Protection Network. She contends the regulatory process has been improperly manipulated to benefit BHP Billiton and has hired attorneys to comb through documents looking for evidence. ***
Although the possible threats of explosion and fire initially drew most public concern about the BHP Billiton project, several risk assessments by independent experts have largely discounted those fears. Even under a worst-case scenario, the analysts concluded, the floating terminal would pose no threat to anyone onshore, although a catastrophic leak and fire could overlap shipping lanes in the Santa Barbara Channel and threaten boaters.

Air pollution has since emerged as the principal focus of contention over the project. Those concerns were heightened by the decision of the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency, which has authority over the project's required air-quality permits, to apply the more lenient pollution standards in place on the Channel Islands rather than the stricter ones applicable onshore.

The agency initially ruled that Ventura County's onshore rules would apply, which would have required BHP Billiton to offset every pound of pollutants associated with the project. The EPA later reversed itself, prompting charges — raised a year ago by critics and echoed this week by Rep. Henry Waxman, chairman of the House Committee on Oversight and Government Reform — that political appointees in the agency had intervened improperly in the regulatory process.
Classic NIMBY behavior.

UPDATE: Download the Report here.

UPDATE2: More here.